It's not a matter of required,its a matter of the number of points of contact,with the normal 3 ,lifter,guide slot or guide plate,and rocker arm the pushrod still has some freedom of movement to change its axis to stay aligned with the lifter seat at the bottom and the rocker arm at the top.With 4 points of contact,lifter,guide slot,guide plate,and rocker arm,the combination of the guide slot and guide plate greatly restricts the pushrods ability to pivot its axis to follow the up and down movement of the lifter and rocker arm,which will impart side loads on the pushrod tips,best case scenario this causes unnecessary wear on the tips and lifter and rocker arm seats,worst case scenario causes at minimum bent pushrods.I would be willing to wager that close inspection of pushrods run with a combination of guide slots and guide plates at minimum would reveal higher than normal wear at the areas where they pass thru the slots or plates.The only scenario where this wouldn't happen is if the lifter bores,guide slots,guide plates,rocker studs,and valve stems were all in perfect alignment for every cylinder,but the odds for this to happen is astronomical so personally I would choose one or the other,more is usually but not always better.