I would think that valve hitting piston would make a mess of any engine , reguardless of piston material. EGGE pistons now come with steel inserts and are $295 , at least that was the last price I paid. I think cast pistons are safe for a 250 hp 348 A/T and 340 hp 409 A/T. Skip Fix raced a 340 hp short block in the 70s with big heads,ketc.. and ran 12s. Millions of cars have gone hundreds of millions of miles with cast pistons. If you use standard trans,. then you will experience the "human factor" that Fred mentioned. Every once in a while, you just gotta nail it . So much fun, you gotta do it again and again. Sooner or later, missed shift, over rev. Pin boss failure is the real problem with cast piston. Too many rpms and the game is over. I do agree with everyone that forged is the only way to go, due to the expense of building these W-heads. But I have several LO-Perf W-heads running around out there with cast pistons. So far , no failures. Forged is way better. No argument here. But I do think there is a certain type car that cast is acceptable. Just my opinion. ( I know, just MY opinion)...........